A Separation

RankCriticPublicationList Year
A.V. Club2011
4David AnsenNewsweek2011
7Mark AschL Magazine2011
3Michael AtkinsonIFC2011
8Saul Austerlitz indiewire poll2011
3Robert AbeleLA Times2011
3Ali ArikanSlant2011
4Juan Carlos ArciniegasCNN2011
7Nigel AndrewFT2011
7Ethan AlterTelevision Without Pity2011
6Evangeline Barbarouxexcessif.com2011
5Thomas Baurezexcessif.com2011
3Peter Bradshaw, The GuardianUK2011
2Chuck BowenSlant Magazine2011
4Sophie Benamonlexpress2011
Ty BurrBoston Glob2011
Livia BloomindieWIRE poll2011
3Dwight BrownNNPA Syndication/Black Press USA.com2011
6Jim Brunzell IIITC Daily Planet2011
8Chris Barsantifilmcritic.com2011
1Criticker.com2011
1Matthew ButcherSkandies2011
10Christophe Chadefaudlexress2011
3Theirry Chezelexpress2011
Godfrey Cheshireindiewire poll2011
9Cashiers du Cinema Espana2011
2Rich Clinecontactmusic.com2011
8Chris CabinFilmcritic.com2011
5David DenbyThe New Yorker2011
1Mike D'Angelo2011
A.A. DowdTime Out Chicago2011
Dawn.com2011
5Michael DunawayPaste Magazine2011
5Matt DentlerindieWIRE2011
7Jeff DeutchmanindieWIRE2011
5Dcist2011
9Richard DurlingSanta Barbara2011
2Anton DolinFilm Comment2011
10Jim Emerson2011
1Roger EbertChicago Sun Times2011
3Bilge EbiriNew York Magazine2011
8Steve EricksonGay City News2011
Phillip FrenchThe Guardian2011
9Marshall FineHuffington Post2011
2David FearNew York Time Out2011
4Film Comment2011
10Jon FroschFrance 242011
Veronika FerdmanSkandies2011
4BryantFrazer, Skandies2011
3Alex FungSkandies2011
4Owen GleibermanEntertainment Weekly2011
8Ed GonzalesSlant2011
4William GossMSN2011
10Stephen GarrettTime Out New York2011
5Leo GoldsmithNot Coming to a Theater Near You2011
3Andrew Grantvillage voice poll2011
Larry GrossVillage Voice film poll2011
4Ray GreeneBox Office Magazine2011
5Peter GutierrezThe Montclair Times2011
Jack GarnerDemocrat and Chronicle.com2011
2Andrea GronvallFreelance2011
1Janos GerebenSan Francisco Chronicle2011
2Steven GreydanusNational Catholic Register2011
7Glenn Heath Jr.Slant Magazine2011
2Tom HallSarasota Film Festival2011
8Eugene HernandezFilm Society of Lincoln Center2011
9Eric HynesReverse Shot2011
6Humo Magazine2011
7Salman HaqqiDawn.com2011
3Peter HowellToronto Star2011
Dennis HarveySan Francisco Bay Guardian2011
9Chris HellerMetro Weekly2011
Carol HemphillWest End World2011
3Alexander HorwatchFilm Comment2011
4Sky HirchkronSkandies2011
3Brian JohnsonMacleans.ca2011
6Caryn JamesindieWIRE2011
3Jake JacobsonWestwood One Radio2011
1Mark JenkinsNPR2011
10Kristin JonesFilm Comment2011
8Simon KinnearTotal Film2011
6Ben KenigsbergTime Out Chicago2011
10Anthony Kaufmanindiewire poll2011
7Eric KohnindieWIRE2011
8Dan KoisWashington Post2011
5Gary KramerGay City News2011
3IndieWire Poll2011
8Lisa KennedyDenver Post2011
9Fabrice Leclerclexpress2011
3Xavier Leherpeurlexpress2011
10Kevin LeeFandor2011
7Robert LevinamNew York2011
Amy Lee and Gazelle EmamiHuffington Post2011
8Diego LererClarin2011
3Phillip LopateFilm Comment2011
5Kevin Laforesthour.ca2011
4Matthew LucasThe Dispatch2011
Ryan LattanzioSan Francisco Bay Guardian2011
11Ben LyonsGlobal Grind2011
2Oliver LytteltonThe Playlist2011
9Ronald LeePinstripe Magazine2011
1Matt MuellerindieWIRE2011
3Noel MurrayAV Club2011
1My Life Is Brilliant.com2011
9Metromix Chicago2011
3Dave McCoy MSN2011
2Peter MartinTwitch2011
5Todd McCarthyHollywood Reporter2011
4Benjamin MercerVillage Voice2011
Neil MorrisIndy Week2011
Eric MelinLawrence.com2011
1Joe MorgensternWall Street Journal2011
3Jose-Lis MoctezumaHydra Magazine2011
Bob MondelloNPR2011
6Kiko MartinezSan Antonio Current2011
4Movie Review Query Engine2011
2Victor MortonSkandies2011
Farran Smith NehmeSelf Styled Siren2011
7Michael NordineHammer to Nail2011
5Nictate2011
6Andrew O'HehirSalon2011
4Michal OleszczykFandor2011
5Sheila O'MaleyCapital New York2011
4Sean O'ConnellHollywood News.com2011
Kurt OsenlundSouth Philly Review2011
7Kyle OsborneArlington Fine Arts Examiner2011
10Charles OdellSkandies2011
2Jason OverbeckSkandies2011
5Keith PhippsAV Club2011
7Michael PhillipsChicago Tribune2011
Matt PaisOrlando Sentinel2011
8Gerald PerryBoston Phoenix2011
6Richard PortonCineaste2011
1Kristy PuchkoFilm Stage2011
7Michael PhillipsChicago Tribune2011
4Gerald PearyBoston Phoenix2011
3Matt PriggePhiladelphia Weekly2011
Claudia PuigUSA Today2011
7Rodrigo PerezPlaylist2011
7The PlaylistNo Author Mentioned2011
1Mark PittilloSkandies2011
9James QuandtArtforum Magazine2011
7Nathan RabinAV Club2011
7Joshua RothkopfTime Out New York2011
5James RocchiMSN2011
5Mark RabinowitzCNN.com2011
9Jordan RaupFilm Stage2011
1Nathaniel RogersFilm Experience2011
3Jim RidleyNashville Scene2011
1Peter RainerThe Christian Science Monitor2011
5Scott RenshawCharleston City Paper2011
3Rene RodriguezMiami Herald2011
3Dre RivasFilm.com2011
8Peter ReiherSkandies2011
2Sight & Sound2011
8The SkinnyUK2011
Stephen SchaefferBoston Herald2011
Dana StevensSlate Magaine2011
5Lisa SchwarzbaumEntertainment Weekly2011
5Slant Magazine2011
3Nick SchagerSlant Magazine2011
4Studio Cine LiveFrench2011
7Clement Sautetlexpress2011
2Jason ShawhanNashville Scene2011
6Matt SingerIFC News2011
5Nigel SmithindiwWIRE2011
4David SterrittTikkun2011
10Cedric SuccivalliICS2011
5Daniel SarathsScreen Invasion2011
Doug StrasslerNew York Press2011
8Total FilmUK2011
13Peter TraversRolling Stone2011
7Kris TapleyinContention2011
3Scott TobiasAV Club2011
Kenneth TuranLos Angeles Times2011
2Ella TaylorNPR2011
3Michael TullyHammer to Nail2011
2Martin TsaiCritic's Notebook2011
6Pete TimmermanPlayback2011
9Bertrand TavernierFilm Comment2011
2Boyd van HoeijVariety2011
9John Von ThadenindieWIRE2011
2Jeff WellsHollywood Elsewhere2011
2Alison WillmoreAV Club2011
4Glenn WhippMSN2011
StephenWhitty, New Jersey Star Ledger2011
Michael WildmanFilm Threat2011
2Chad Webb411 Mania2011
3Adam WhyteWhat Culture2011
6Daniel WatersSkandies2011
8Blake WilliamsSkandies2011
5Ryan WuSkandies2011
4John BeifussMemphis Commercial Appeal2012
4James BerardinelliReelviews2012
Anthony GinnaneSenses of Cinema Poll2012
1J.R. JonesChicago Reader2012
3Glenn SumiNOW Magazine2012
8Steven WarrenWindy City Times2012