| Erica Abeel | Huffington Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Sam Adams | LA Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Atkinson | IFC | 2009 | Yes |
| American Film Institute | | 2009 | No |
| Sean Axmaker | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Austin Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| African American Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Melissa Anderson | The Village Voice | 2009 | Yes |
| John Anderson | Variety | 2009 | Yes |
| Mark Asch | The L Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Saul Austerlitz | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Robert Abele | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Jason Anderson | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| David Ansen | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Chas Andrews | Louisville mojo.com | 2009 | No |
| Billups Allen | Tucson Citizen | 2009 | No |
| Jeanne Aufmuth | Palo Alto Online News | 2009 | Yes |
| Bob Allen | Denton RC | 2009 | No |
| Peg Aloi | Times Union.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Jeffrey M. Anderson | Cinematical | 2009 | Yes |
| Thelma Adams | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | 2009 | Yes |
| Alliance of Women Film Journalists | | 2009 | No |
| Jay Antani | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Beth Accomando | KPBS | 2009 | Yes |
| Al Alexander | The Patriot Ledger | 2009 | Yes |
| Academy Awards | | 2009 | No |
| Richard Brody | New Yorker | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Brunette | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Broadcast Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Donna Bowman | A.V. Club | 2009 | Yes |
| Dwight Brown | NNPA Syndication | 2009 | Yes |
| Ray Bennett | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Marjorie Baumgarten | The Austin Chronicle | 2009 | Yes |
| Matt Brunson | Creative Loafing | 2009 | Yes |
| Sheila Benson | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Xan Brook | The Guardian | 2009 | No |
| Linda Barnard | The Star | 2009 | Yes |
| Bill Brownstein | Montreal Gazette | 2009 | Yes |
| Ty Burr | Boston Globe | 2009 | Yes |
| Bob Bloom | jconline.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Liz Braun | The Observer | 2009 | Yes |
| James Bernardinelli | ReelViews | 2009 | No |
| Brad Brevet | Rope of Silicon | 2009 | No |
| Dan Bennett | North Country Times | 2009 | No |
| Kyle Buckhanan | Movieline | 2009 | No |
| Brian Brooks | indieWIRE | 2009 | No |
| Jim Brunzell III | TC Daily Planet | 2009 | Yes |
| Josh Board | San Diego Reader | 2009 | No |
| Ian Bunting | Advertiser | 2009 | Yes |
| Bruce Bennett | The Spectrum.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Kim Brown | Tulsa World | 2009 | Yes |
| Jessica Barnes | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Josh Bell | Las Vegas Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Robert W. Butler | Kansas City Star | 2009 | Yes |
| Nathan Bloch | Spike.com | 2009 | No |
| Amy Biancolli | Chron.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Bumbray | JoBlo.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Jenna Busch | JoBlo.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Rick Bentley and Donald Munro | Fresno Bee | 2009 | No |
| Chris Barsani | filmcritic.com | 2009 | No |
| Paul Brenner | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Keith Breese | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| John Beifuss | Go memphis | 2009 | Yes |
| Geoff Berkshire | Metromix.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Tim Brayton | Antagonie | 2009 | Yes |
| Brussat | Spirituality & Practice | 2009 | No |
| Sean Burns | Philadelphia Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Black | Review Express | 2009 | Yes |
| Merrick Bursuk | The Stephen Holt Show | 2009 | No |
| Richard Corliss | Time Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Nick Clarke | TM5 | 2009 | No |
| Daryl Chin | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | No |
| Fernando F. Croce | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| James Carroll | Epoch Times | 2009 | No |
| Canwest News Service | | 2009 | No |
| Jeannette Catsoulis | New York Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Travis Crawford | IndieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Canadian Press | | 2009 | No |
| Cashier du Cinema | | 2009 | No |
| Justin Chang | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Tom Charity | CNN | 2009 | Yes |
| Godfrey Cheshire | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Jackie Cooper | WPGA TV | 2009 | No |
| Bob Chipman | the escapist | 2009 | No |
| Christian Science Monitor | | 2009 | No |
| Rob Christopher | Chicagoist | 2009 | No |
| Linda Cook | Quad City Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Matt Connolly | Times Herald record | 2009 | No |
| Brendan Campbell | Inside Pulse Movies | 2009 | No |
| Peter Canavese | Palo Alto Online News | 2009 | Yes |
| Craig Courtice | National Post | 2009 | No |
| Gary Cogill | WFAA.com | 2009 | No |
| Katie Carter | St. Louis Movie Examiner | 2009 | No |
| Cheap Canuck | Associated Content | 2009 | No |
| Kevin Coll | Fused Film.com | 2009 | No |
| Michael Compton | BG Daily News.com | 2009 | No |
| Central Ohio Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| CinemaSpy.com | | 2009 | No |
| Keith Cohen | Sun Publications | 2009 | Yes |
| Carol Cling | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Cabin | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Pete Croatto | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| C. Robert Cargill | Film.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Francis Chervenak | The Stephen Holt Show | 2009 | No |
| Keith Collins | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| David Denby | New Yorker | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Debruge | Variety | 2009 | No |
| Mike D'Angelo | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | No |
| Marcy Dermansky | About.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Dallas Fort Worth Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Mahola Dargis | New York Times | 2009 | No |
| Robert Davis | Paste magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| David D'Arcy | Screen International | 2009 | No |
| Rob Driscoll | Wales Online | 2009 | Yes |
| Joel D Amos | Sheknows.com | 2009 | No |
| Bob Denerstein | INDenverTimes.com | 2009 | No |
| Edward Douglas | ComingSoon.net | 2009 | No |
| The Dude | Movies Online.ca | 2009 | No |
| Tony Daniel | Newnan Times-Herald.com | 2009 | No |
| Constance Droganes | CTV.ca | 2009 | No |
| Karen Durbin | ELLE magazine | 2009 | No |
| John Depko and Suzanne Perez | Daily Pilot | 2009 | No |
| Gary Dretzka | | 2009 | No |
| Aaron Dobbs | Out of Focus | 2009 | No |
| Duane Dudek | Milwaukee Wisconsin Journal Sentinel | 2009 | Yes |
| Rossiter Drake | SF Station | 2009 | Yes |
| Shawn Edwards | Fox-TV | 2009 | No |
| Cheryl Eddy | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2009 | No |
| Steve Erickson | Gay City News | 2009 | Yes |
| Jim Emerson | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Gregory Ellwood | Hitfix | 2009 | Yes |
| Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun-Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Bilge Ebiri | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| David Ehrenstein | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| David Edelstein | NPR | 2009 | Yes |
| Ken Eisner | Georgia Straight | 2009 | Yes |
| David Fear | Time Out New York | 2009 | Yes |
| Jurgen Fauth | Fictionaut | 2009 | Yes |
| Cynthia Fuchs | Pop Matters | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Farber | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Film Comment | | 2009 | No |
| FX Feeney | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Scott Foundas | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Noah Forrest | Movie City News | 2009 | No |
| John Foote | News Durham Region | 2009 | No |
| Bob Fishbach | Omaha World-Herald | 2009 | No |
| Film.com | | 2009 | No |
| Malcolm Fraser | Montreal Mirror | 2009 | No |
| Lexi Feinberg | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Blake French | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Father Geek | Ain't It Cool News | 2009 | No |
| Marshall Fine | Hollywood & Fine | 2009 | Yes |
| Bryant Frazer | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Alex Fung | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Golden Sats Top 10 | | 2009 | No |
| Susan Gerhard | SF360.org | 2009 | No |
| Leo Goldsmith | Not Coming to a Theater Near You | 2009 | Yes |
| Ed Gonzalez | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Andrew Grant | Like Anna Karina's Sweater | 2009 | Yes |
| David Germain | Associated Press | 2009 | Yes |
| Tim Grierson | LA Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Owen Gleiberan Entertainment Weekly | | 2009 | No |
| Lance Goldenberg | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Larry Gross | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| John Griffin | Montreal Gazette | 2009 | Yes |
| Matt Goldberg | Collider.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Todd Gilchrist | Cinematical | 2009 | Yes |
| Bob Green | Honolulu Weekly | 2009 | No |
| Mike Giuliano | Catonsville Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Jack Garner | ROCnow | 2009 | Yes |
| Danny Gire | Daily Herald | 2009 | No |
| Bill Goodykoontz | Gannett | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Garcia | American-State Film | 2009 | Yes |
| Bob Grimm | Big Island Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Susan Granger | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Bill Gibron | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Tom Hall | Sarasota Film Festival | 2009 | No |
| Aaron Hillis | GreenCine Daily | 2009 | Yes |
| Eric Hynes | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Robert Horton | The Herald | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Holden | New York Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Ann Hornaday | Washington Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Brandon Harris | Filmmaker Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Kirk Honeycutt | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Hartlaub | San Francisco Chronicle | 2009 | Yes |
| Eugene Hernandes | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Logan Hill | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| J Hoberman | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Christoph Huber | Village Voice | 2009 | Yes |
| Houston Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Peter Howell | The Star | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Hewitt | St. Paul Pioneer Press | 2009 | No |
| Stan Hall | The Oregonian | 2009 | Yes |
| Todd Hill | Silive.com | 2009 | No |
| John Harding | Explore Howard.com | 2009 | No |
| Carol Hemphill | Webster-Kirkwood Times | 2009 | No |
| Addam Hardy | The Film Stage | 2009 | No |
| John Hansen | California Chronicle | 2009 | No |
| Matthew Hays | Montreal Mirror | 2009 | Yes |
| Jesse Hassenger | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| A.J. Hakari | Review Express | 2009 | No |
| Curt Holman | Creative Loafing | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Holt | The Stephen Holt Show | 2009 | No |
| Skander H | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Jeremy Heilman | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Sky Hirschkron | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Chrissie Iles | Artforum | 2009 | No |
| Bruce | Ingram, Pioneer Press | 2009 | No |
| J.R. Jones | Chicago Reader | 2009 | No |
| Richard T. Jameson | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Mark Jenkins | NPR | 2009 | Yes |
| Caryn James | Maire Claire | 2009 | Yes |
| Kristin M. Jones | Film Comment | 2009 | Yes |
| Brian D. Johnson | Maclean.ca | 2009 | Yes |
| Kent Jones | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Janusonis | The Providence Journal | 2009 | Yes |
| Todd Jorgenson | Denton Record Chronicle | 2009 | Yes |
| Matthew Jackson | The Hunstsville Item | 2009 | No |
| MaryAnn Johanson | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Jimmyo | JoBlo.com | 2009 | No |
| Rachel Jacobson | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Bill Krohn | The Economist | 2009 | No |
| Laura Kern | Film Comment | 2009 | Yes |
| Eric Kohn | inidieWIRE | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Koresky | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Gary Kramer | Gay City News | 2009 | No |
| Don Kaye | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Ben Kenigsberg | Time Out Chicago | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Knegt | indieWIRE | 2009 | No |
| Dan Kois | Washington Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Christopher Kelly | Fort Worth Star-Telegram | 2009 | Yes |
| Glenn Kenny | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Keough | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Robert Koehler | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Sean Patrick Kernan | Zoiks! Online | 2009 | No |
| Harry Knowles | Ain't It Cool News | 2009 | No |
| Zorianna Kit | California Literary Review | 2009 | No |
| Chuck Koplinski | Illinois Times | 2009 | No |
| Barry Koltnow | Victoria Advocate | 2009 | No |
| Rick Kaplan | National Posts | 2009 | No |
| Carl Kozlowski | Pasadena Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Andy Klein | BrandX | 2009 | Yes |
| Jette Kernion | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Dan Kane | Smyrna Clayton Sun Times | 2009 | No |
| Kevyn Knox | The Burg | 2009 | No |
| TC Kirkham | Popcorn and Roses | 2009 | No |
| Anthony Lane | New Yorker | 2009 | Yes |
| Les Cashiers du Cinema | | 2009 | No |
| Mick LaSalle | San Francisco Chronicle | 2009 | Yes |
| Joe Leydon | Variety | 2009 | Yes |
| Dennis Lim | Moving Image Source | 2009 | Yes |
| Karina Longworth | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Phillip Lopate | New York Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Christy Lemire | Associated Press | 2009 | Yes |
| Joshua Land | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Joseph Jon Lanthier | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Lou Lumenick | New Yok Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Nathan Lee | Film Comment | 2009 | Yes |
| Sheri Linden | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Andy Layer | indieWIRE | 2009 | No |
| Eric Lavallee | iconcinema.com | 2009 | No |
| Kevin B. Lee | Time Out New York | 2009 | Yes |
| Tim Lammers | At the Movies | 2009 | No |
| Diego Lerer | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Amy Longsdorf | The Morning Call | 2009 | No |
| Shawn Levy | The Oregonian | 2009 | Yes |
| Matthew Lucas | The Dispatch | 2009 | No |
| Kevin Laforest | Montreal Film Journal | 2009 | No |
| Kristian Lin | Fort Worth Weekly | 2009 | No |
| Tom Long | Detroit News | 2009 | Yes |
| Travis Leamons | Inside Movies Pulse | 2009 | No |
| Craig D. Lindsey | The News and Observer | 2009 | Yes |
| Christopher Lloyd | Herald Tribune | 2009 | Yes |
| Jeff Leins | News in Film | 2009 | No |
| Jim Luksic | Santa Ynez Valley Journal | 2009 | No |
| George Lang | News OK | 2009 | No |
| Ann Lewinson | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Joanna Langfield | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Laremy Legal | Film.com | 2009 | No |
| Robert Levin | amNew York | 2009 | Yes |
| Patrick Z. McGavin | Lightsensitive.typepad.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Sam Means | The Salt Lake Tribune | 2009 | No |
| Kristi Mitsuda | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Noel Murray | A.V. Club | 2009 | No |
| Dave McCoy | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Kim Morgan | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Kathleen Murphy | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Brian Miller | Seattle Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Amy Monaghan | Pullquote | 2009 | No |
| V.A. Musetto | New York Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Miami New Times (Foundas | Wionsky, Hoberman) | 2009 | No |
| MSN | | 2009 | No |
| Todd McCartney | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Wesley Morris | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Moviephone Staff | | 2009 | No |
| Michuk Filmaster.com | | 2009 | No |
| Joe Morgenstern | Wall Street Journal | 2009 | No |
| Drew McWeeny | HitFix | 2009 | No |
| Neil Miller | film school rejects | 2009 | No |
| Moira Macdonald | Seattle Times | 2009 | No |
| Ben Mankiewicz | Turner Classic Movies | 2009 | Yes |
| Marc Mohan | The Oregonian | 2009 | Yes |
| Scott Marks | San Diego New Room | 2009 | No |
| Bob Mondello | All Things Considered | 2009 | No |
| Kiko Martinez | WOAI.com | 2009 | No |
| Mark Medley | National Post | 2009 | No |
| Bruce Miller | Sioux City Journal | 2009 | No |
| Jason McKiernan | Filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Erik Morse | SF Bay Guardian | 2009 | No |
| Neil Morris | Indy Week.com | 2009 | No |
| Rebecca Murray | About.com | 2009 | No |
| Scott Mendelson | The Huffington Post | 2009 | No |
| Paul Myers | fanbolt.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Dave Mar | Athens Flagpole | 2009 | No |
| Jennifer Merin | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Brandy McDonnell | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Nell Minnow | Movie Mom | 2009 | No |
| Tony Macklin | Las Vegas Weekly | 2009 | No |
| Moviefone | | 2009 | No |
| Katherine Monk | Calgary Herald | 2009 | No |
| Amanda Mae Meyncke | Film.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Whitney Matheson | USA Today PopCandy | 2009 | Yes |
| Martin Malloy | SF Station | 2009 | No |
| Martin Morrow | CBC News | 2009 | No |
| Eric Merlin | Scene-Stealers | 2009 | No |
| Don Marks | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Jeff McCloud | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Victor Morton | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| National Board of Review | | 2009 | No |
| Adam Nayman | Eye Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| New York Film Critics Online | | 2009 | No |
| Rob Nelson | Variety | 2009 | Yes |
| Joe Neumaier | New York Daily News | 2009 | Yes |
| Mike Noyes | Inside Pulse Movies | 2009 | No |
| Michael Nowotny | Montain Home News | 2009 | No |
| Christopher Null | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Nictate | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Mark Olsen | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| The Onion | | 2009 | No |
| Michelle Orange | Movieline | 2009 | Yes |
| Oklahoma Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Sean O'Connell | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Clint O'Connor | Cleveland Plain Dealer | 2009 | Yes |
| Andrew O'Hehir | Salon | 2009 | Yes |
| Becca Owsley | The News Enterprise | 2009 | No |
| Brian Orndorf | Moviehole.net | 2009 | Yes |
| Tricia Olszewski | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Devin D. O'Leary | Alibi.com | 2009 | No |
| Charles Odell | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Jason Overbeck | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Matt Prais | metromix Chicago | 2009 | No |
| Gerald Peary | Boston Phoenix | 2009 | Yes |
| Andre Picard | Cinema Scope | 2009 | No |
| Richard Porton | Cineaste | 2009 | Yes |
| Mary Pols | MSN | 2009 | No |
| Paste Magazine | | 2009 | No |
| Keith Phipps | The Onion | 2009 | Yes |
| David Poland | Movie City News | 2009 | Yes |
| Ray Pride | Movie City Indie | 2009 | Yes |
| Ryan Michael Painter | In This Week | 2009 | No |
| Phoenix Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Michael Phillips | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Nick Pinkerton | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| John Powers | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Sheridan Passell | Movie Moron | 2009 | No |
| Steve Persall | St. Petersburg Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Pop Wrap | | 2009 | No |
| Peter Paras | E! Online | 2009 | Yes |
| Troy Patterson | SPIN.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Ned Prickett | Blast Magazine | 2009 | No |
| Jon Plaut | Independent Press | 2009 | No |
| Steve Prokopy | Gapers Block | 2009 | No |
| Betsy Pickle | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Claudia Puig | USA Today | 2009 | Yes |
| Matt Prigge | Philadelphia Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Mark Pittillo | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| James Quandt | Artforum Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Jeff Reichert | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Jonathan Rosenbaum | Chicago Reader | 2009 | Yes |
| James Rocchi | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| Nathan Rabin | The Onion | 2009 | Yes |
| Tasha Robinson | The Onion | 2009 | Yes |
| Richard Roeper | Chicago Sun-Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Rechtshaffen | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Nicholas Rapold | Film Comment | 2009 | No |
| Jeff Rizov | IFC.com | 2009 | No |
| Lisa Rosman | US Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Joshua Rothkopf | Time Out New York | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Joshua Rowin | indieWIRE poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Berenice Reynaud | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Carrey Rickey | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Rene Rodriguez | Miami Herald | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Rea | Philadelphia Inquirer | 2009 | No |
| Aida Rusli | The Malaysian Insider | 2009 | No |
| Katey Rich | Cinema Blend | 2009 | Yes |
| Mike Russell | The Oregonian | 2009 | Yes |
| Neil Rosen | NY1 | 2009 | Yes |
| Rex Reed | NY Observer | 2009 | Yes |
| Peter Rainer | The Christian Science Monitor | 2009 | Yes |
| Iann Robinson | Crave | 2009 | Yes |
| George Roush | Latino Review | 2009 | No |
| Zach Ralston | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Peter Reihler | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Scott Renshaw | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Sight and Sound | | 2009 | No |
| Nick Schager | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Southestern Film Critics | | 2009 | No |
| Andrew Schenker | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Ryan Steward | Slant Magazine | 2009 | No |
| Slant Magazine | | 2009 | No |
| Mike Sampson | JoBlo.com | 2009 | No |
| A.O. Scott | New York Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Lisa Schwarzbaum | Entertainment Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Jay Stone | National Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Kyle Smith | New York Post | 2009 | Yes |
| Frank Scheck | The Hollywood Reporter | 2009 | Yes |
| Jason Shawhan | The Tenessean | 2009 | No |
| Matt Singer | IFC News | 2009 | Yes |
| David Sterritt | Tikkun | 2009 | Yes |
| Benjamin Strong | Poor Richard | 2009 | Yes |
| R. Emmet Sweeney | Movie Morlocks | 2009 | Yes |
| Betsy Sharkey | Los Angeles Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Choire Sicha | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Chuck Stephens | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Julian Sancton | Vanity Fair | 2009 | No |
| Dana Stevens | Slate | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Scharfer | Boston Herald | 2009 | No |
| Jason Solomons | The Guardian | 2009 | Yes |
| Salt Lake Tribune | | 2009 | No |
| Jeff Simon | California Chronicle | 2009 | No |
| Jim Slotek | The Observer | 2009 | Yes |
| Reg Seeton | the deadBolt.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Mike Scott | The Times-Picayune | 2009 | Yes |
| Bob Strauss | Pasadena Star-News | 2009 | Yes |
| D.M. Sanders | Minneapolis Examiner | 2009 | No |
| Shlmo Schwartzberg | Bloor Cinema Magazine | 2009 | No |
| Russ Simmons | KC Tribune | 2009 | No |
| Star News Online | | 2009 | No |
| Erik D. Snider | Film.com | 2009 | No |
| Robert Sutton | Inside Pulse Movies | 2009 | No |
| Scott Sawitz | Inside Pulse Movies | 2009 | No |
| Robert Saucedo | Inside Pulse Movies | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Sragow | Baltimore Sun | 2009 | Yes |
| Don Sanchez | KGO-TV | 2009 | No |
| Mike Shultz | River Cities' Reader | 2009 | No |
| Josh Spence | You Been Blinded.com | 2009 | No |
| Mike Sage | myKawartha.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Melissa Starker | Columbus Alive | 2009 | Yes |
| Steve Salles | Standard-Examiner | 2009 | No |
| Christopher Sykes | Montreal Mirror | 2009 | No |
| Mark Slutsky | Montreal Mirror | 2009 | No |
| Marc Savlov | Austin Chroincle | 2009 | Yes |
| Ruth Stein | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Diana Saenger | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |
| Shelli Sonstein | AWFJ | 2009 | No |
| Norm Schrager | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Sasha Stone | Awards Daily | 2009 | Yes |
| Brad Schreiber | Huffington Post | 2009 | No |
| Irv Slifkin | Movies Unlimited | 2009 | No |
| Dan Sallitt | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Missy Schwartz | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Sicinski | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Stults | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Peter Travers | Rolling Stone | 2009 | Yes |
| Anne Thompson | Thompson on Hollywood | 2009 | Yes |
| Amy Taubin | Film Comment | 2009 | Yes |
| Charles Taylor | Fox on the Prowl | 2009 | Yes |
| Scott Tobias | A.V. Club | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Tully | Hammer to Nail | 2009 | No |
| Kris Tapley | In Contention | 2009 | No |
| Kenneth Turan | Los Angeles Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Luke Y. Thompson | E! Online | 2009 | Yes |
| NP Thompson | Village Voice poll | 2009 | No |
| Martin Tsai | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Elle Taylor | Village Voice | 2009 | No |
| Kent Tentschert | Webster-kirkwood Times | 2009 | No |
| Josh Tyler | Cinema blend.com | 2009 | No |
| Susan Tavernetti | Palo Alto Online | 2009 | Yes |
| Chauncey Telese | KHTS AM 1220 | 2009 | No |
| Gene Triplett | NewsOK | 2009 | No |
| Brian Tallerico | Movie retriever | 2009 | Yes |
| Josh Tate | Laist | 2009 | No |
| Jonne Thornborough | The Daily Journal | 2009 | No |
| Rob Thomas | Madison Capital Times | 2009 | Yes |
| Keith Uhlich | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Joel Urbanich | Sun Papers | 2009 | No |
| USA Today | | 2009 | No |
| Elbert Ventura | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Boyd van Hoeij | Variety | 2009 | Yes |
| Phil Villarreal | OK! Magazine! | 2009 | Yes |
| Village Voice | | 2009 | No |
| Greg Vellante | The Eagle-Tribune | 2009 | No |
| Lynn Venhaus | News Democrat | 2009 | No |
| Suzanne Van Atten | Atlanta Journal Constitution | 2009 | No |
| Joan Vadeboncoeur | Syracuse Post Standard | 2009 | No |
| Barbara Vancheri | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette | 2009 | Yes |
| Kim Voynar | Movie City News | 2009 | Yes |
| Rob Vaux | fimcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Mel Valentin | SF Station | 2009 | Yes |
| Froilan Vispo | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| John Waters | Artforum | 2009 | No |
| Glenn Whipp | MSN | 2009 | Yes |
| David Walsh | World Socialist Web Site | 2009 | No |
| Matthew Wilder | Collider | 2009 | No |
| Chuck Wilson | LA Weekly | 2009 | Yes |
| Chris Wisniewski | Reverse Shot | 2009 | Yes |
| Susan Wloszczyna | USA Today | 2009 | Yes |
| Bill Weber | Slant Magazine | 2009 | Yes |
| Elizabeth Weitzman | New York Daily News | 2009 | Yes |
| Armond White | New York Press | 2009 | Yes |
| Stephen Whitty | The Star-Ledger | 2009 | Yes |
| Alison Willmore | IFC.com | 2009 | Yes |
| We Are Movie Geeks.com | | 2009 | No |
| Bill White | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| James Ward | Visalia Times Delta | 2009 | No |
| Kevin | Williamson, The Observer | 2009 | No |
| Steve Warren | The Windy City Times | 2009 | No |
| L. Kent Wolgamott | Lincoln Journal Star | 2009 | No |
| Lisa Westerfield | Gather.com | 2009 | No |
| Chris Williams | Advisor & Source | 2009 | No |
| Gary Wolcott | atomictown.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Michael Wilmington | | 2009 | Yes |
| Mike Ward | Richmond Screen Scene | 2009 | Yes |
| Mark Walters | BIGFANBOY.com | 2009 | No |
| Jeff Walls | Seattle Post Intelligencer | 2009 | No |
| Drew Wheeler | flagpole.com | 2009 | No |
| Don Willmott | filmcritic.com | 2009 | Yes |
| Scott Weinberg | Cinematical | 2009 | Yes |
| Daniel Waters | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Andrew Wright | Skandies | 2009 | Yes |
| Ryan Wu | Skandies | 2009 | No |
| Stephanie Zacharek | Village Voice poll | 2009 | Yes |
| Jen Yamato | AWFJ | 2009 | Yes |