| David Ansen | Newsweek | 2004 | Yes |
| Thelma Adams | US Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| The Advocate | | 2004 | No |
| John Anderson | Newsday | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Atkinson | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Saul Austerlitz | Film Threat/ Senses of Cinema | 2004 | Yes |
| Melissa Anderson | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Soren Andersen | Tacoma News Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Jay Antani | L.A. Alternative Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Erica Abeel | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Jason Anderson | eye Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Alan Abbott | Louisville Eccentric Observer | 2004 | No |
| Sam Adams | Philadelphia City Paper | 2004 | Yes |
| William Arnold | Seattle Post-Intelligencer | 2004 | Yes |
| Boo Allen | Denton Record-Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Al Alexander | The Patriot Ledger | 2004 | Yes |
| Edith Alderette | San Francisco Examiner | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeffrey M. Anderson | San Francisco Examiner | 2004 | Yes |
| Victoria Alexander | Films in Review | 2004 | Yes |
| Tim Appelo | Seattle Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Marie Asner | The Phantom Tollbooth / Shawnee Journal-Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| Ross Anthony | Ross Anthony's Hollywood Report Card | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeanne Aufmuth | Palo Alto Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Jami Bernard | New York Daily News | 2004 | Yes |
| Cameron Bailey | NOW Toronto | 2004 | No |
| Wendy Banks | NOW Toronto | 2004 | No |
| David Blaylock | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Ty Burr | Boston Globe | 2004 | Yes |
| Rob Butler | Defactoweb.com | 2004 | No |
| Bonnie Britton | Indianapolis Star | 2004 | No |
| Robert W. Butler | Kansas City Star | 2004 | Yes |
| Christopher Borrelli | Toledo Blade | 2004 | Yes |
| Joe Baltake | Sacramento Bee | 2004 | Yes |
| Frederic & Mary Ann Brussat | Spirituality & Health | 2004 | No |
| Liz Braun | Toronto Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Rick Barton | New Orleans Gambit Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Sean Burns | Philadelphia Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Liza Bear | indieWIRE | 2004 | No |
| Brian Brooks | indieWIRE | 2004 | No |
| Peter Brunette | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| James Berardinelli | ReelViews | 2004 | Yes |
| Richard von Busack | Metroactive / Metro Santa Cruz | 2004 | Yes |
| Matt Brunson | Creative Loafing Charlotte | 2004 | Yes |
| Dan Bennett | North County Times | 2004 | No |
| Jay Bobbin | WNYT-TV | 2004 | No |
| Mark Burger | Winston-Salem Journal | 2004 | No |
| John Boonstra | Connecticut Advocate Weekly Newspapers | 2004 | No |
| Angela Baldassarre | Sympatico.ca | 2004 | Yes |
| Tom Brook (BBC World | Talking Movies) | 2004 | No |
| Wallace Baine | Santa Cruz Sentinel | 2004 | Yes |
| Ed Blank | Pittsburgh Tribune-Review | 2004 | No |
| Colin Boyd | Las Vegas City Life | 2004 | No |
| Philip Booth | Sarasota Herald-Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Ed Bradley | The Flint Journal | 2004 | No |
| Rob Blackwelder | SPLICEDwire | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Booth | Denver Post | 2004 | Yes |
| Harper Barnes | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | 2004 | Yes |
| Chris Barsanti | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Jules Brenner | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| David N. Butterworth | OFFOFFOFF | 2004 | Yes |
| Baltimore City Paper | | 2004 | No |
| Greg Beacham | Salt Lake City Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Donna Bowman | Nashville Scene | 2004 | Yes |
| Marjorie Baumgarten | Austin Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Brett Buckalew | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| John Beifuss | Commercial Appeal | 2004 | Yes |
| Eric Beltmann | Flipside Movie Emporium | 2004 | No |
| Jeffrey Bruner | Des Moines Register | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Burns | Chesapeake Bay Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Carina Chocano | LA Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Arch Campbell | | 2004 | No |
| Jen Cameron | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Joseph Cunneen | National Catholic Reporter | 2004 | No |
| Richard Corliss | Time | 2004 | Yes |
| Kevin Courrier | Box Office Magazine/CBC Radio | 2004 | Yes |
| Leslie Camhi | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Tom Charity | Lovefilm/Time Out London | 2004 | Yes |
| Godfrey Cheshire | The Independent Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Daryl Chin | Journal of Performance & Art | 2004 | No |
| David Chute | LA Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Travis Crawford | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Edward Crouse | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Joanna Connors | Cleveland Plain Dealer | 2004 | Yes |
| Rich Copley | Lexington Herald-Leader | 2004 | No |
| Carol Cling | Las Vegas Review-Journal | 2004 | Yes |
| Keith Cohen | Sun Publications | 2004 | Yes |
| Jackie K. Cooper | Jackie K Cooper.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Jess Cagle | CBS Early Show | 2004 | No |
| Shala Carlson | New Orleans Gambit Weekly | 2004 | No |
| TT Clinkscales | Cincinnati CityBeat | 2004 | No |
| Laura Clifford | Reeling Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Robin Clifford | Reeling Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Mike Clark | USA Today | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeanette Catsoulis | Las Vegas Mercury | 2004 | No |
| Charles Cassady Jr. | Cleveland Free Times | 2004 | No |
| Kenneth Chanko | Stephen Holt Show | 2004 | No |
| Nicholas Collias | Boise Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Colin Covert | Minneapolis Star Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Kyle Counts | Gay & Lesbian Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Gary Cogill | WFAA-TV | 2004 | No |
| Kevin Capp | Las Vegas City Life | 2004 | No |
| Paul Clinton | CNN | 2004 | No |
| Mark Collette | Tyler Morning Telegraph | 2004 | Yes |
| Bill Chambers | Film Freak Central | 2004 | Yes |
| Walter Chaw | Film Freak Central | 2004 | Yes |
| Barry Caine | Oakland Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Cory Cheney | Urban Tulsa Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Jill Cozzi | Mixed Reviews | 2004 | No |
| Peter Canavese | Groucho Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Pete Croatto | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Sean Chavel | Cinema Confidential | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeffrey Chen | Window to the Movies | 2004 | Yes |
| Larry Carroll | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| Elaine Corden | Vancouver Westender | 2004 | No |
| Andrea Chase | Killer Movie Reviews / Movie Magazine International | 2004 | Yes |
| Erik Childress | eFilmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Micheal Compton | Bowling Green Daily News | 2004 | No |
| Lorilee Craker | Grand Rapids Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Rick Curnutte | The Film Journal | 2004 | No |
| Manohla Dargis | The New York Times | 2004 | No |
| Mike D'Angelo | Time Out New York | 2004 | No |
| Gary Dretzka | Movie City News | 2004 | No |
| Robert Denerstein | Dallas Rocky Mountain News | 2004 | No |
| Thomas Doherty | Cinéaste | 2004 | No |
| Scott Von Doviak | Culture Vulture | 2004 | No |
| Edward Douglas | ComingSoon.net | 2004 | No |
| Paul Dearing | Jackson Free Press | 2004 | No |
| Brian Dukes | Up and Coming Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Anthony Del Valle | Las Vegas Mercury | 2004 | Yes |
| John Defore | Austin American-Statesman | 2004 | No |
| Thomas Delapa | Boulder Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Nick Digilio | WGM Radio Chicago | 2004 | No |
| Duane Dudek | Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel | 2004 | Yes |
| Sandi Davis | The Oklahoman | 2004 | No |
| Marcy Dermansky | About.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Steve Davis | Austin Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Nick Davis | Nick's Flick Picks | 2004 | Yes |
| Cherryl Dawson | The Movie Chicks | 2004 | No |
| James DiGiovanni | Tucson Weekly | 2004 | No |
| John Douglas | Grand Rapids Press | 2004 | No |
| Mark Dujsik | OFCS | 2004 | No |
| Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun-Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Shawn Edwards | Fox | 2004 | No |
| E! Online | | 2004 | No |
| David Ehrenstein | New Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Justine Elias | The Guardian | 2004 | Yes |
| David Edelstein | Slate | 2004 | Yes |
| David Elliott | San Diego Union-Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Suzanne Ellis | Canada.com | 2004 | No |
| Cheryl Eddy | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | No |
| Steve Erickson | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Paul Ennis | Festival Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| Simon Ennis | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Hap Erstein | Palm Beach Post | 2004 | Yes |
| EDGE Boston | | 2004 | No |
| John Esther | Pasadena Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Ken Eisner | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| Annlee Ellingson | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Elliott | Movie Parables | 2004 | No |
| Gregory Ellwood | MSN Entertainment - Hollywood Hitlist | 2004 | Yes |
| Entertainment Insiders | | 2004 | No |
| Scott Foundas | LA Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Graham Fuller | Interview | 2004 | Yes |
| Patrick Ferrucci | New Haven Register | 2004 | No |
| Chris Fujiwara | Boston Phoenix | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeff Farance | Daytona Beach News-Journal | 2004 | No |
| Phoebe Flowers | Florida Sun-Sentinel | 2004 | Yes |
| Don Fowler | Warwick Beacon | 2004 | No |
| Roger Friedman | Fox News | 2004 | No |
| Howard Feinstein | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Cindy Fuchs | Philadelphia City Paper | 2004 | No |
| Bob Fischbach | Omaha World-Herald | 2004 | No |
| Film Threat | | 2004 | No |
| Blake French | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| John H. Foote | Hollywood North | 2004 | No |
| Scott Feinberg | WTNH-TV | 2004 | No |
| Jürgen Fauth | About.com | 2004 | No |
| David Fellerath | Independent Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Felicia Feaster | Creative Loafing Atlanta | 2004 | Yes |
| Dana Kopp Franklin | Nashville Rage | 2004 | No |
| Sara M. Fetters | Moviefreak.com | 2004 | No |
| Fresno Bee | | 2004 | No |
| Ed Gonzalez | Slant Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| David Germain | AP | 2004 | Yes |
| Owen Gleiberman | EW | 2004 | Yes |
| John Griffin | Montreal Gazette | 2004 | Yes |
| Susan Granger | Susan Granger Syndicate | 2004 | Yes |
| Martin Grove | Hollywood Reporter | 2004 | No |
| Susan Gerhard | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | No |
| Max Goldberg | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephen Garrett | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Jack Garner | Gannett News Service | 2004 | Yes |
| Lance Goldenberg | Tampa Weekly Planet | 2004 | Yes |
| Steve Gravestock | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Chris Garcia | Austin American-Statesman | 2004 | Yes |
| Andy Gray | Warren Tribune Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Bob Grimm | Las Vegas City Life / Reno News & Review | 2004 | Yes |
| Eleanor Ringel Gillespie | Atlanta Journal-Constitution | 2004 | No |
| Dann Gire | Chicago Daily Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| Andrea Gronvall | OFFOFFOFF | 2004 | Yes |
| Dave Gathman | Suburban Chicago News | 2004 | No |
| Rick Grant | Entertaining U Jacksonville | 2004 | No |
| Chuck Graham | Tucson Citizen | 2004 | No |
| Todd Gilchrist | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| Pam Grady | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| Berge Garabedian | JoBlo.com | 2004 | No |
| Chris Gladden | Roanoke Times | 2004 | No |
| Steven D. Greydanus | Decent Films Guide | 2004 | Yes |
| Peter Howell | Toronto Star | 2004 | Yes |
| Ron Henriques | Latino Review | 2004 | No |
| John Harkness | Now Toronto | 2004 | Yes |
| Matthew Hays | Montreal Mirror | 2004 | Yes |
| John Hartl | MSNBC | 2004 | Yes |
| Ed Halter | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Holcomb | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Deborah Hornblow | Hartford Courant | 2004 | No |
| Louis B. Hobson | Calgary Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| J. Hoberman | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Laurie Hibberd | CBS Early Show | 2004 | No |
| Dennis Harvey | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | Yes |
| Eugene Hernandez | indieWIRE | 2004 | No |
| Fiona Hughes | The Vancouver Courier | 2004 | No |
| Eric Harrison | Houston Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephen Holden | The New York Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephen Holt | Stephen Holt Show | 2004 | No |
| Lori Hoffman | Atlantic City Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Robert Horton | Everett Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| Sara Havens | Louisville Eccentric Observer | 2004 | No |
| Forrest Hartman | Reno Gazette-Journal | 2004 | Yes |
| Ralph Hammann | Metroland New York | 2004 | No |
| Travis Hoover | Film Freak Central | 2004 | No |
| Mark Hinson | Tallahassee Democrat | 2004 | No |
| Dan Hudak | Coral Gables Gazette/ Broward Informer | 2004 | Yes |
| Chris Hewitt | Pioneer Press | 2004 | No |
| Jesse Hassenger | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Tim Hager | Up& Coming Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Jeremy Heilman | Movie Martyr | 2004 | Yes |
| Curt Holman | Creative Loafing Atlanta | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Harris | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| Ken Hanke | Asheville Mountain Xpress | 2004 | Yes |
| Tyler Hanley | Palo Alto Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Neil Harvey | Roanoke Times | 2004 | No |
| George Hatza | Reading Eagle | 2004 | No |
| Chrissie Iles | Artforum | 2004 | No |
| IGN FilmForce | | 2004 | No |
| James Israel | indieWIRE | 2004 | No |
| Paul Isaacs | eye Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Bruce Ingram | Pioneer Press Chicago | 2004 | Yes |
| Brian D. Johnson | Macleans | 2004 | Yes |
| Kent Jones | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Brandon Judell | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| MaryAnn Johanson | The Flick Filosopher | 2004 | Yes |
| Todd Jorgenson | Denton Record-Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Janusonis | The Providence Journal | 2004 | Yes |
| JR Jones | Chicago Reader | 2004 | No |
| Kimberly Jones | Austin Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Mark Jenkins | Washington City Paper | 2004 | Yes |
| Andrew Jefchak | Grand Rapids Press | 2004 | No |
| Chris Jenness | Kenai Peninsula Clarion | 2004 | No |
| Beth Jones | Roanoke Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Scott Juba | The Trades | 2004 | No |
| Melora Koepke | Montreal Hour | 2004 | No |
| Ben Kenigsberg | East Hampton/Southhampton Independent | 2004 | Yes |
| Peter Keough | Boston Phoenix | 2004 | Yes |
| Leonard Klady | Movie City News | 2004 | Yes |
| Stuart Klawans | The Nation | 2004 | Yes |
| Bruce Kirkland | Toronto Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Glenn Kenny | Premiere | 2004 | Yes |
| Anthony Kaufman | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeremiah Kipp | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| C.D. Kaplan | Louisville Eccentric Observer | 2004 | No |
| Paul Kopasz | Louisville Eccentric Observer | 2004 | No |
| Harry Kloman | Pittsburgh City Paper | 2004 | No |
| Rick Kisonak | Seven Days Vermont | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael H. Kleinschrodt | New Orleans Times-Picayune | 2004 | No |
| Chris Kaltenbach | Baltimore Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Jarret Keene | Las Vegas City Life | 2004 | No |
| Matt Kelemen | Las Vegas City Life | 2004 | Yes |
| Anita Katz | San Francisco Examiner | 2004 | Yes |
| Harry Knowles | Ain't It Cool News | 2004 | No |
| Lisa Kennedy | Denver Post | 2004 | Yes |
| Harvey Karten | Arizona Reporter / CompuServe | 2004 | No |
| Richard Knight, Jr. | Windy City Times | 2004 | No |
| Christopher Kelly | Fort Worth Star-Telegram | 2004 | Yes |
| Andy Klein | LA CityBeat | 2004 | Yes |
| Larry Katz | Westminster Community Times | 2004 | No |
| Gareth Von Kallenbach | sknr.net | 2004 | No |
| David Keyes | Cinemaphile.org | 2004 | Yes |
| Robert Koehler | Variety | 2004 | Yes |
| Erich Kuersten | Pop Matters | 2004 | Yes |
| Emanuel Levy | emanuellevy.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Christy Lemire | AP | 2004 | Yes |
| Tom Long | The Detroit News | 2004 | Yes |
| Joshua Land | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Nathan Lee | New York Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Shawn Levy | The Oregonian | 2004 | Yes |
| Terry Lawson | Detroit Free Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Lou Lumenick | New York Post | 2004 | Yes |
| Mick LaSalle | San Francisco Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Joanna Langfield | The Movie Minute | 2004 | Yes |
| Dave Larsen | Dayton Daily News | 2004 | Yes |
| Arthur Lazere | Culture Vulture | 2004 | Yes |
| Kevin LaForest | Montreal Film Journal | 2004 | No |
| Dennis Lim | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Jonny Leahan | indieWIRE | 2004 | No |
| Kristian Lin | Fort Worth Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Barbara Lester | South Florida City Link | 2004 | Yes |
| Tim Lammers | IBS @ The Movies | 2004 | No |
| Jean Lowerison | San Diego Metropolitan | 2004 | Yes |
| Bob Longino | Atlanta Journal-Constitution | 2004 | Yes |
| George Lang | The Oklahoman | 2004 | No |
| Christopher Lloyd | Ocala Star-Banner | 2004 | Yes |
| Laura Leon | Metroland New York | 2004 | No |
| Floyd Lawrence | Erie Times-News | 2004 | No |
| Josh Larsen | Suburban Chicago News | 2004 | Yes |
| Kim Linekin | eye Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Germain Lussier | Times Herald-Record | 2004 | No |
| Robert Loerzel | Pioneer Press Chicago | 2004 | No |
| David Levine | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Tom Lynch | New City Chicago | 2004 | No |
| Amy Longsdorf | New Jersey Courier-Post | 2004 | No |
| Jonathan Lewis | Gay Chicago Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| Jonathan Lampley | Nashville Rage | 2004 | No |
| John Lekich | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| John Larsen | Light Views / Ventura County Reporter | 2004 | No |
| Joe Leydon | Variety / The Moving Picture Show | 2004 | Yes |
| Kurt Loder | MTV | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeffrey Lyons | WNBC-TV | 2004 | Yes |
| Jack Matthews | New York Daily News | 2004 | No |
| Dave Micevic | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Jay Millikan | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Wilson Morales | blackfilm.com | 2004 | No |
| Rebecca Murray | About.com | 2004 | No |
| Jason McBride | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Musto | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Mike Mayo | Movie Show Radio | 2004 | Yes |
| Philip Martin | Arkansas Democrat Gazette | 2004 | No |
| V.A. Musetto | New York Post | 2004 | Yes |
| Wesley Morris | Boston Globe | 2004 | No |
| Moira Macdonald | Seattle Times | 2004 | No |
| Carla Meyer | San Francisco Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Nell Minow | Yahoo Movies/ Movie Mom | 2004 | No |
| Gary Mairs | Culture Vulture | 2004 | Yes |
| Roger Moore | Orlando Sentinel | 2004 | No |
| Brian Miller | Seattle Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Wendy Mitchell | indieWIRE | 2004 | Yes |
| Wayne Melton | Richmond Style Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Joel McConvey | eye Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Margaret A. McGurk | Cincinnati Enquirer | 2004 | Yes |
| Sean P. Means | The Salt Lake Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Andrew McIntosh | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Bill Muller | Arizona Republic | 2004 | Yes |
| Dave McCoy | MSN Entertainment | 2004 | Yes |
| J. Caleb Mozzocco | Columbus Alive | 2004 | No |
| Danny Minton | KBTV-TV / DannyMinton.com | 2004 | No |
| Bob Mondello | NPR | 2004 | No |
| Bruce R. Miller | Sioux City Journal | 2004 | No |
| Katherine Monk | The Vancouver Sun | 2004 | No |
| The Movie Guys | Tony | 2004 | No |
| The Movie Guys | Phil | 2004 | No |
| George Meyer | Sarasota Herald-Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Joe Morgenstern | The Wall Street Journal | 2004 | No |
| Ann Morrow | Metroland New York | 2004 | No |
| Leonard Maltin | Entertainment Tonight / Leonard Maltin.com | 2004 | No |
| Sean McBride | KFDM-TV / The Port Arthur News | 2004 | Yes |
| Greg Maki | Easton Star Democrat | 2004 | No |
| Praire Miller | Long Island Press | 2004 | No |
| Paul Matwychuk | Vue Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| M.V. Moorhead | Erie Times-News | 2004 | Yes |
| Eric Meyerson | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Mike McGranaghan | The Aisle Seat | 2004 | No |
| Tim Miller | Cape Cod Times | 2004 | No |
| Noel Murray | The Onion / Nashville Scene | 2004 | No |
| Movie Habit | | 2004 | No |
| Eric Melin | Lawrence | 2004 | No |
| Patrick McGavin | Chicago Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Beth McArthur | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| Scott Manzler | Nashville Scene | 2004 | No |
| Priscilla Mack | Westminster Community Times | 2004 | No |
| John McCarthy | Cinema Syndicate | 2004 | No |
| Bill McCuddy | Fox News | 2004 | No |
| Drew "Moriarty" McWeeny | Ain't It Cool News | 2004 | No |
| Michael Medved | The Michael Medved Show | 2004 | Yes |
| Marty Meltz | Portland Press Herald | 2004 | No |
| Marci Miller | Asheville Mountain Xpress | 2004 | No |
| Veronica Mixon | Film Gazette | 2004 | Yes |
| Robert Moyes | Monday Magazine | 2004 | No |
| David Ng | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Tim Nasson | Wild About Movies | 2004 | No |
| Howie Nave | Tahoe Daily Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Nick Nunziata | Chud.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Eugene Novikov | Film Blather | 2004 | Yes |
| Adam Nayman | eye Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Bruce Newman | San Jose Mercury News | 2004 | Yes |
| Daniel Neman | Richmond Times-Dispatch | 2004 | Yes |
| Jon Niccum | Lawrence Journal-World | 2004 | Yes |
| Elise Nakhnikian | Princeton Packet | 2004 | Yes |
| New Times (Bill Gallo | Melissa Levine, Jean Oppenheimer, Luke Y | 2004 | No |
| Christopher Null | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Rob Nelson | City Pages | 2004 | Yes |
| David Nusair | Reel Film Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Robert Newton | Worcester Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| Craig Outhier | Orange County Register | 2004 | Yes |
| Geoffrey O'Brien | Library of America/Film Comment | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Olsen | LA Weekly/ Sight & Sound | 2004 | Yes |
| James Owen | Film Snobs | 2004 | No |
| Sean O'Connell | WCNC-TV | 2004 | Yes |
| Austin O'Connor | MediaNews | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeffrey Overstreet | Looking Closer | 2004 | Yes |
| Frank Ochieng | World Journal | 2004 | Yes |
| Brian Orndorf | FilmJerk | 2004 | Yes |
| Devin D. O'Leary | Albuquerque Alibi | 2004 | No |
| James Quandt | Artforum | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Palermo | The Coast | 2004 | Yes |
| Gerald Peary | Boston Phoenix | 2004 | Yes |
| Steve Persall | St. Petersburg Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Ed Park | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Peranson | Village Voice/eye | 2004 | Yes |
| Richard Porton | Film Journal International | 2004 | Yes |
| John Powers | LA Weekly/NPR's Fresh Air | 2004 | Yes |
| Mary F. Pols | Contra Costa Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Jon Popick | Planet Sick-Boy | 2004 | Yes |
| Jesse Paddock | Culture Vulture | 2004 | Yes |
| Rodger Pille | Cincinnati CityBeat | 2004 | No |
| Claudia Puig | USA Today | 2004 | Yes |
| Milan Paurich | Cleveland Free Times | 2004 | No |
| Betsy Pickle | Knoxville News Sentinel | 2004 | No |
| Jamie Peters | Louisville Eccentric Observer | 2004 | No |
| Barry Paris | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette | 2004 | No |
| David Poland | Movie City News | 2004 | Yes |
| Geoff Pevere | Toronto Star | 2004 | Yes |
| Jonathan Perry | Tyler Morning Telegraph | 2004 | Yes |
| Jonathan Plumtree | Echo Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Dayna Papaleo | Rochester City Newspaper | 2004 | No |
| Dan Pearson | Chicago Daily Southtown | 2004 | No |
| J. Robert Parks | The Phantom Tollbooth | 2004 | Yes |
| Keith Phipps | The Onion | 2004 | Yes |
| Leigh Ann Palone | The Movie Chicks | 2004 | No |
| Ray Pride | Movie City News | 2004 | Yes |
| Dustin Putman | themovieboy.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Richard Roeper | Chicago Sun Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Jonathan Romney | Artforum | 2004 | Yes |
| Leah Rozen | People | 2004 | Yes |
| J.T. Ramsay | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Troy Reimink | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Robert Rosado | efilmcritic.com | 2004 | No |
| Sarah Rowland | Montreal Mirror | 2004 | No |
| Rex Reed | New York Observer | 2004 | Yes |
| Bérénice Reynaud [misc] | | 2004 | No |
| Mike Rubin | Village Voice | 2004 | No |
| Lisa Rose | New Jersey Star-Ledger | 2004 | Yes |
| Steven Rea | Philadelphia Inquirer | 2004 | Yes |
| Carrie Rickey | Philadelphia Inquirer | 2004 | Yes |
| Rene Rodriguez | Miami Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| Larry Ratliff | San Antonio Express-News | 2004 | Yes |
| Luisa F. Ribeiro | L.A. Alternative Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Steve Ramos | Cincinnati CityBeat | 2004 | Yes |
| Steven Rosen | Cincinnati CityBeat | 2004 | Yes |
| Neil Rosen | NY1-TV | 2004 | Yes |
| B. Ruby Rich | Village Voice / San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | Yes |
| John Reardon | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Peter Roffman | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Laura Roebuck | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Bob Ross | Tampa Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Dean Richards | WGM Radio Chicago | 2004 | No |
| Eric Robinette | Middletown Journal | 2004 | No |
| Scott Renshaw | Salt Lake City Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Carlos Reyes | Prensa Hispana | 2004 | No |
| Nathan Rabin | The Onion | 2004 | Yes |
| James Rocchi | Netflix | 2004 | Yes |
| Jim Ridley | City Pages / Nashville Scene | 2004 | Yes |
| Joshua Rothkopf | Nashville Scene | 2004 | Yes |
| Reverse Shot | | 2004 | No |
| Jonathan Rosenbaum | Chicago Reader | 2004 | Yes |
| Nathaniel Rogers | The Film Experience | 2004 | Yes |
| Craig Roush | Kinnopio's Movie Reviews | 2004 | No |
| Lisa Schwarzbaum | EW | 2004 | Yes |
| Richard Schickel | Time | 2004 | Yes |
| Ron Stringer | LA Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Gene Seymour | Newsday | 2004 | Yes |
| David Sterritt | The Christian Science Monitor | 2004 | Yes |
| Jan Stuart | Newsday | 2004 | Yes |
| Nick Schager | Slant Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| A.O. Scott | The New York Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Randy Shulman | Metro Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Shlomo Schwartzberg | Box Office Magazine/ Festival | 2004 | Yes |
| Laura Sinagra | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Robert Sklar | Houston Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Gregory Solman | DVD Express/ Senses of Cinema | 2004 | Yes |
| Elliott Stein | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Benjamin Strong | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Ruthe Stein | San Francisco Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Bob Strauss | Los Angeles Daily News | 2004 | Yes |
| Chuck Schwartz | Cranky Critic | 2004 | No |
| Chuck Stephens | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeff Simon | Buffalo News | 2004 | No |
| Matt Zoller Seitz | New York Press | 2004 | Yes |
| David Lee Simmons | New Orleans Gambit Weekly | 2004 | No |
| Gabriel Shanks | Mixed Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Peter Sobczynski | eFilmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Sam Sokolove | San Diego CityBeat | 2004 | No |
| Steve Sullivan | Ames Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Cole Smithey | MauiTime Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Scott Siegel | Stephen Holt Show | 2004 | No |
| Jeff Strickler | Minneapolis Star Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Linda Hoy Socha | Sun Newspapers Ohio | 2004 | No |
| Gerry Shamray | Sun Newspapers Ohio | 2004 | Yes |
| James Sanford | Kalamazoo Gazette | 2004 | Yes |
| Melissa Starker | Columbus Alive | 2004 | Yes |
| Joel Siegel | Good Morning America | 2004 | Yes |
| Michael Sragow | Baltimore Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Mike Szymanski | Zap2it.com | 2004 | No |
| Jay Stone | The Vancouver Sun | 2004 | Yes |
| Amanda Shurr | Sarasota Herald-Tribune | 2004 | No |
| Leslie Gray Streeter | Palm Beach Post | 2004 | No |
| Steve Salles | Utah Standard-Examiner | 2004 | No |
| Juan-Carlos Selznick | Chico News & Review | 2004 | No |
| Matt Soergel | Florida Times-Union | 2004 | Yes |
| David Spaner | Vancouver Province | 2004 | No |
| Shawn Stone | Metroland New York | 2004 | No |
| Norm Schrager | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Hank Sartin | Chicago Free Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Eric D. Snider | Eric D Snider.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Terri Sutton | City Pages | 2004 | No |
| Andrew Sarris | New York Observer | 2004 | Yes |
| Marc Savlov | Austin Chronicle | 2004 | Yes |
| Janet Smith | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| Erik Samdahl | Movie-Source | 2004 | No |
| Mike Schulz | River Cities Reader | 2004 | No |
| Martin Scribbs | Mixed Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Mark Sells | Oregon Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| John Serba | Grand Rapids Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Duncan Shepherd | San Diego Reader | 2004 | No |
| Dan Singleton | The Phantom Tollbooth | 2004 | No |
| Christopher Smith | Bangor Daily News | 2004 | Yes |
| Colin Souter | eFilmcritic.com | 2004 | No |
| Ian Spelling | Film Stew | 2004 | Yes |
| Sasha Stone | Santa Monica Mirror / Oscarwatch | 2004 | Yes |
| Adam Suraf | The Dunkirk Observer / In Review | 2004 | No |
| Amy Taubin | Artforum | 2004 | Yes |
| Kenneth Turan | LA Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Kevin Thomas | LA Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Peter Travers | Rolling Stone | 2004 | Yes |
| Ken Tucker | New York Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| Josh Timmermann | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | Yes |
| Ella Taylor | LA Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Charles Taylor | Salon | 2004 | Yes |
| Bob Tremblay | MetroWest Daily News | 2004 | No |
| Stephen J. Truog | Northwest Indiana Times | 2004 | No |
| Rob Thomas | Madison Rhythm | 2004 | Yes |
| Pamela Troy | Culture Vulture | 2004 | Yes |
| Betty Jo Tucker | ReelTalk Movie Reviews | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephen Tringali | Hershey Chronicle | 2004 | No |
| Catharine Tunnacliffe | eye Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Lawrence Toppman | Charlotte Observer | 2004 | Yes |
| Dawn Taylor | Portland Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| Desson Thomson | Washington Post | 2004 | Yes |
| Gene Triplett | The Oklahoman | 2004 | No |
| Joshua Tanzer | OFFOFFOFF | 2004 | Yes |
| Joshua Tyler | Cinema Blend | 2004 | Yes |
| David Thomas | Filmcritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Roger Tennis | Cinema CLIPS | 2004 | Yes |
| Scott Tobias | The Onion | 2004 | Yes |
| N.P. Thompson | Movies Into Film | 2004 | No |
| George M. Thomas | Akron Beacon Journal | 2004 | No |
| Martin Tsai | Vancouver Westender | 2004 | Yes |
| Susan Tavernetti | Palo Alto Weekly | 2004 | Yes |
| Steve Taylor | WHQR Public Radio | 2004 | No |
| Luke Y. Thompson | New Times | 2004 | Yes |
| Peter Tonguette | The Film Journal | 2004 | Yes |
| Stan Urankar | Sun Newspapers Ohio | 2004 | No |
| John Urbancich | Sun Newspapers Ohio | 2004 | Yes |
| Phil Villarreal | Arizona Daily Star | 2004 | Yes |
| Mal Vincent | Norfolk Virginian-Pilot | 2004 | Yes |
| Chris Vognar | Dallas Morning News | 2004 | Yes |
| James Verniere | Boston Herald | 2004 | Yes |
| Barbara Vancheri | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeff Vice | Deseret News | 2004 | Yes |
| Rob Vaux | Flipside Movie Emporium | 2004 | Yes |
| Joan E. Vadeboncoeur | Syracuse Post-Standard | 2004 | No |
| Michael Wilmington | Chicago Tribune | 2004 | Yes |
| John Waters | Artforum | 2004 | No |
| Kevin Worrall | Stylus Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Jeffrey Wells | Hollywood Elsewhere | 2004 | Yes |
| Norman Wilner | Metro Toronto | 2004 | Yes |
| Jessica Winter | Village Voice | 2004 | Yes |
| Glenn Whipp | Los Angeles Daily News | 2004 | Yes |
| William Wolf | Wolf Entertainment Guide | 2004 | No |
| Max Weiss | Movie Show Radio | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephen Whitty | Newark Star-Ledger | 2004 | Yes |
| David Wildman | Boston Weekly Dig | 2004 | Yes |
| George Wu | Culture Vulture | 2004 | Yes |
| Susan Woods | Lansing City Pulse | 2004 | No |
| Jason Whyte | eFilmcritic.com | 2004 | No |
| David Weaver | Festival Magazine | 2004 | No |
| Gil Whiteley | Denver Daily News | 2004 | No |
| Philip Wuntch | Dallas Morning News | 2004 | Yes |
| Ron Wynn | Nashville City Paper | 2004 | No |
| Eric Wolters | Middletown Journal | 2004 | No |
| Jan Wahl | KRON-TV4 / San Francisco Examiner | 2004 | No |
| James Ward | Visalia Times-Delta | 2004 | No |
| Steve Warren | Dallas Voice | 2004 | No |
| Bill Wine | KYW Newsradio | 2004 | No |
| L. Kent Wolgamott | Lincoln Journal Star | 2004 | No |
| Joe Williams | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | 2004 | Yes |
| Calvin Wilson | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | 2004 | Yes |
| Jeff Westhoff | Northwest Herald | 2004 | No |
| David Walsh | World Socialist | 2004 | No |
| Scott Weinberg | eFilmCritic.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Matthew Wilder | City Pages | 2004 | No |
| Mike Ward | Richmond.com | 2004 | Yes |
| Armond White | NY Press | 2004 | Yes |
| Ron Yamauchi | Georgia Straight | 2004 | Yes |
| Stephanie Zacharek | Salon | 2004 | Yes |
| Andy Zientek | Kinnopio's Movie Reviews | 2004 | No |