Rank	Critic	Publication	List Year
6	Ben Harrison	Toronto Film Review	2016
3	Oli Lyttelton	The Playlist	2016
5	Movie Waffler		2016
8	Seth Needle	Screen Media	2016
6	Nicolas Rapold	Film Comment	2016
	Dash Shaw	Director	2016
	Thelma Adams	Real Clear Life	2017
8	Sam Allard	Cleveland Scene	2017
1	Preston Barta	Denton Record-Chronicle	2017
5	William Bibbiani	Crave	2017
	Ty Burr	Boston Globe	2017
10	Nick Chandler	Hidden Remote	2017
10	Noah Damon	Defacto Film Review	2017
	Simon Ennis	Toronto Film Comment	2017
6	Steve Erickson	RogerEbert.com	2017
3	David Fear	Rolling Stone	2017
5	Veronika Ferdman	Skandies	2017
4	Josh	Filmspotting	2017
	The 405		2017
9	Haileigh Foutch	Collider	2017
8	Jon Frosch	Hollywood Reporter	2017
10	Jacob Hall	Slash Film	2017
7	Angie Han	Mashable.com	2017
9	Aaron Hillis	Village Voice Film Poll	2017
8	Jordan Hoffman	The Guardian	2017
9	io9 Staff		2017
	Mark Kermode	The Observer	2017
7	Walter King	RogerEbert.com	2017
2	Lola Landekic	Toronto Film Review	2017
4	Josh Larsen	Village Voice Film Poll	2017
8	Christy Lemire	ChristyLemire.com	2017
	Oliver Lunn	I-D Vice	2017
10	Vince Mancini	UPROXX	2017
	Megan Moffat	Toronto Film Review	2017
	Newsweek		2017
5	Amy Nicholson	UPROXX	2017
8	Tony Nunes	Geek Dad	2017
8	Ryan Oliver	The Playlist	2017
9	Paste Magazine		2017
8	Adam Patterson	Film Pulse	2017
8	Michael Phillips	Chicago Tribune	2017
	Harry Raji	Junkee	2017
8	Jared Rasic	Source Weekly	2017
9	Mike Reyes	Cinema Blend	2017
10	John Semley	Toronto Globe & Mail	2017
7	Allison Shoemaker	RogerEbert.com	2017
4	Justine Smith	Roger Ebert.com	2017
9	Eric D. Snider	ericdsnider.com	2017
7	Shane Scott-Travis	Taste of Cinema	2017
10	Andrew Todd	Birth.Movies.Death.	2017
8	UPROXX		2017
6	Eric Walkuski	JoBlo.com	2017
5	Kathleen Walsh	Village Voice Film Poll	2017
4	Daniel Waters	Skandies	2017
8	Allison Willmore	BuzzFeed	2017
	April Wolfe	Village Voice	2017
	Kevin Young	Charleston City Paper	2017