| Allocine.fr | | 2008 | No |
| Thelma Adams | US Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| AFI | | 2008 | No |
| John Anderson | Newsday | 2008 | Yes |
| Melissa Anderson | Time Out New York | 2008 | Yes |
| Austin Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Saul Austerlitz | Boston Globe | 2008 | Yes |
| Sean Axmaker | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Atkinson | ICF | 2008 | Yes |
| African American Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Greg Archer | SF Examiner | 2008 | No |
| Jason Anderson | Eye Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Mark Asch | The L Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| David Ansen | Newsweek | 2008 | Yes |
| Ethan Alter | Giant Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Alliance of Women Journalists | | 2008 | No |
| Sam Adams | Philadelphia City Paper | 2008 | Yes |
| Al Alexander | The Patriot Ledger | 2008 | Yes |
| Jeffrey Anderson | Las Vegas Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Arizona Daily Star | | 2008 | No |
| Erica Abeel | IndieWire | 2008 | Yes |
| Acquarello | Auteurs Workbook | 2008 | No |
| Bob Allen | Denton Record-Chronicle | 2008 | No |
| Alibi.com | | 2008 | No |
| Michelle Alexandria | Eclipse Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Jeanne Aufmuth | Palo Alto | 2008 | Yes |
| Jay Antanni | filmcritic.com | 2008 | No |
| William Arnold | Seattle Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Broadcast Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Peter Brunette | Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Donna Bowman | The A.V. Club | 2008 | Yes |
| Richard Brody | The New Yorker | 2008 | Yes |
| Marjorie Baumgarten | Austin Chronicle | 2008 | Yes |
| Merrick Bursuk | Stephen Holt Show | 2008 | No |
| Ty Burr | Boston Globe | 2008 | Yes |
| Sonny Bunch | Washington Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Josh Bell | Las Vegas Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Robert Butler | Kansas City Star | 2008 | No |
| Ray Bennett | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Kim Brown | Popcorn n Roses | 2008 | Yes |
| Brad Brevet | Rope of Silicon | 2008 | No |
| Nathan Bloch | Spike.com | 2008 | No |
| Brian Brooks | IndieWire | 2008 | No |
| Amy Biancolli | Houston Chronicle | 2008 | Yes |
| Matt Brunson | Creative Loafing | 2008 | Yes |
| Dwight Brown | Seattle Medium | 2008 | Yes |
| Jim Brunzell | TC Daily Planet | 2008 | No |
| Chris Bumbray | JoBlo.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Hannah Brown | post.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Rick Bentley | The Fresno Bee | 2008 | Yes |
| David Blaustein | ABC News | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Barsanti | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Paul Brenner | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| John Beifuss | Go Memphis | 2008 | Yes |
| Geoff Berkshire | Metro Mix | 2008 | Yes |
| Tim Brayton | Antagony & Ectasy | 2008 | Yes |
| Frederic Brussat | Spirituality & Practice | 2008 | No |
| Sean Burns | Philadelphia Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| James Berardinelli | ReelViews | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Black | Review Express | 2008 | Yes |
| Bruce Bennett | The Spectrum | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Beaumont | Blogcritics Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Matthew Butcher | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Richard Corliss | Time Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Stuart Comer | Tate Modern | 2008 | No |
| Karen Cooper | Film Forum NY | 2008 | No |
| Tom Charity | CNN | 2008 | Yes |
| Travis Crawford | Film Comment | 2008 | Yes |
| Jeannette Catsoulis | New York Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Daryl Chin | http://www.d-a-c.blogspot.com | 2008 | No |
| Canadian Press | | 2008 | No |
| Sheigh Crabtree | Women On Film | 2008 | No |
| James Crawford | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Peter Canavese | Groucho Reviews | 2008 | Yes |
| Keith Cohen | Sun Publications | 2008 | Yes |
| Francis Chervenak | Stephen Holt Show | 2008 | No |
| Carol Cling | Las Vegas Review Journal | 2008 | Yes |
| Colin Colvert | Minneapolis Star Tribune | 2008 | No |
| Gary Congill | KVUE | 2008 | No |
| Richard Crouse | Canada AM | 2008 | No |
| Charles Cassady Jr. | Cleveland Scene | 2008 | No |
| Arch Campbell | | 2008 | No |
| Michael Compton | Bowling Green Daily News | 2008 | No |
| Marco Cerritos | Firstshowing.net | 2008 | Yes |
| Laurie Coker | The Hill Country News | 2008 | No |
| Chris Cox | Spill.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Robert Cargill | Spill.com | 2008 | No |
| Jon Chattman | The Huffington Post | 2008 | No |
| Chris Cabin | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Brian Chen | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Walter Chaw | Film Freak Central | 2008 | Yes |
| Bill Chambers | Film Freak Central | 2008 | Yes |
| Robin Clifford | Reeling Reviews | 2008 | Yes |
| Laura Clifford | Reeling Reviews | 2008 | Yes |
| Linda Cook | Go & Do | 2008 | Yes |
| Gina Carbone | Sea Coast Online | 2008 | Yes |
| Matt Cale | Ruthless Reviews | 2008 | No |
| Criticker.com | | 2008 | No |
| Jay Cheel | FilmJunk.com | 2008 | No |
| Dave Cowen | skandies | 2008 | No |
| David Denby | The New Yorker | 2008 | Yes |
| Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Mike D'Angelo | Las Vegas Weekly | 2008 | No |
| Peter DeBruge | Variety | 2008 | No |
| Phil Dzikiy | Niagra Gazette | 2008 | No |
| Manohla Dargis | New York Times | 2008 | No |
| Robert Davis | Paste Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Joe DeShano | MTV | 2008 | No |
| Aaron Dobbs | Out of Focus | 2008 | No |
| Marcy Demansky | About.com | 2008 | No |
| David D'Arcy | Screen | 2008 | No |
| Alonso Duralde | MSNBC.com | 2008 | No |
| Roger Durling | Santa Brabara Independent | 2008 | No |
| Duane Dudek | Milwaukee Wisconsin Journal Sentinel | 2008 | Yes |
| Edward Douglas | Coming Soon | 2008 | No |
| Rossiter Drake | San Francisco Examiner | 2008 | Yes |
| Cole Dabney | Insite Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Victor Diaz | News 8 Austin | 2008 | No |
| Erik Davis | Cinematical | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Drakulich | Southtown Star | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Dance | The Cinema Source | 2008 | Yes |
| Dan Deevy | The Cinema Source | 2008 | No |
| Marc Doyle | Metacritic.com | 2008 | No |
| Michael Duberowski | Criticstop10.com | 2008 | No |
| Tony Dayoub | CinemaViewfinder | 2008 | Yes |
| Sean Dwyer | FilmJunk.com | 2008 | No |
| Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun-Times | 2008 | Yes |
| David Edlestein | New York Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Shawn Edwards | Fox TV | 2008 | No |
| Greg Ellwood | MSN | 2008 | No |
| Jim Emerson | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Cheryl Eddy | San Francisco Bay Guardian | 2008 | No |
| Steve Erickson | Gay City News | 2008 | Yes |
| Laura Emerick | Chicago Sun-Times | 2008 | Yes |
| David Edelstein | Fresh Air | 2008 | Yes |
| Bilge Ebiri | New York Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Ken Eisner | Straight.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Charles Ealy | Austin American Statesman | 2008 | Yes |
| Edge Boston | | 2008 | No |
| Empire | | 2008 | No |
| Marshall Fine | Hollywood and Fine | 2008 | Yes |
| Film Comment Magazine | | 2008 | No |
| Phillip French | The Observer | 2008 | No |
| David Fear | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Jurgen Fauth | About.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Cynthia Fuchs | popmatters.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Graham Fuller | Freelance | 2008 | Yes |
| Fox News | | 2008 | No |
| Film Comment Contributors | | 2008 | No |
| Lexi Feinberg | Big Picture Big Sound | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Farber | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| John Foote | In Contention | 2008 | No |
| Film Comment | | 2008 | No |
| Howard Feinstein | IndieWire | 2008 | Yes |
| Scott Foundas | LA Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Brandon Fibbs | Colorado Springs Gazette | 2008 | Yes |
| Roger Friedman | Fox News | 2008 | No |
| Blake French | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| David Faraci | CHUD | 2008 | No |
| Garth Franklin | Dark Horizons | 2008 | Yes |
| Russ Fischer | CHUD.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Film Junk | | 2008 | No |
| Bryant Frazer | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Alex Fung | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Paul Gallagher | Future Movies.co.uk | 2008 | Yes |
| David Germain | AP | 2008 | Yes |
| Ed Gonzalez | Slant Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Bill Goodykoontz | Arizona Republic | 2008 | Yes |
| Owen Gleiberman | Entertainment Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| The Guardian | | 2008 | No |
| Susan Gerhard | SF360.org | 2008 | No |
| Andrew Grant | filmbrain.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Leo Goldsmith | Not Coming to a Theater Near You | 2008 | Yes |
| Susan Granger | SSG Syndicate | 2008 | Yes |
| Rafer Guzman | Newsday | 2008 | Yes |
| Pam Grady | Film Stew | 2008 | Yes |
| Jason Guerrasio | Fimmaker Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Jason Gargano | Cincinnati City Beat | 2008 | No |
| Mike Giuliano | Howard County Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Raphy Grant | Queerty.com | 2008 | No |
| Janos Gereben | San Francisco Examiner | 2008 | Yes |
| Rick Groen | Toronto Globe and Mail | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Garcia | Austin American Statesman | 2008 | Yes |
| Pat Graham | Chicago Reader | 2008 | Yes |
| Phil Gibron | filmcritic.com | 2008 | No |
| William Goss | efilmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Andrea Gronvall | Chicago Reader | 2008 | Yes |
| Gayot.com | | 2008 | No |
| Greg Gaspari | FilmJunk.com | 2008 | No |
| Giles Hardie | Sydney Morning Herald | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Hall | The Back Row Manifesto | 2008 | No |
| Brandon Harris | Spout | 2008 | Yes |
| Aaron Hillis | Village Voice | 2008 | Yes |
| Grady Hendrix | Variety Asia | 2008 | Yes |
| J Hoberman | Village Voice | 2008 | No |
| Eric Hynes | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Holden | New York Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Liz Helfgott | Criterian Collection | 2008 | No |
| Dan Hudak | Australia.to News | 2008 | Yes |
| Houston Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Jenny Halper | Spare Change News | 2008 | Yes |
| Robert Horton | roberthorton.wordpress.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Holt | Stephen Holt Show | 2008 | No |
| Chris Hewitt | St Paul Pioneer Press | 2008 | No |
| Peter Hartlaub | San Francisco Gate | 2008 | Yes |
| Peter Howell | Toronto Star | 2008 | Yes |
| Todd Hill | Staten Island Advance | 2008 | No |
| Kirk Honeycutt | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Hawley | Twitch | 2008 | No |
| Dennis Harvey | Variety | 2008 | Yes |
| Mark Harris | Straight.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Ann Hornaday | Washington Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Eugene Hernandez | IndieWire | 2008 | No |
| Mark Hinson | Tallahassee.com | 2008 | No |
| Carol Hemphill | Webster - Kirkwood Times | 2008 | No |
| Barry Hertz | The National Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Tyler Hanley | Palo Alto | 2008 | Yes |
| Jesse Hassenger | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Ken Hanke | Mountain Express | 2008 | Yes |
| Lori Hoffman | Atlantic City Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Peter Vonder Haar | Film Threat | 2008 | No |
| A.J. Hakari | Review Express | 2008 | No |
| Skander H. | Skandies | 2008 | No |
| Sky Hirschkron | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Bruce Ingram | Sun-Times News Group | 2008 | Yes |
| Bob Ignizio | Cleveland Scene | 2008 | No |
| International Cinephile Society | | 2008 | No |
| Richard Jameson | MSN Movies | 2008 | No |
| jvrabel | islandpacket.com | 2008 | No |
| JR Jones | Chicago Reader | 2008 | No |
| Mark Jenkins | npr.org | 2008 | Yes |
| MaryAnn Johanson | FlickFilosopher.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Kristin Jones | Film Comment | 2008 | No |
| Just Press Play Writers | | 2008 | No |
| Patty Jones | Straight.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Kimberly Jones | Austin Chronicle | 2008 | No |
| Michael Janusonis | Providence Journal | 2008 | Yes |
| Matthew Jackson | The Huntsville Item | 2008 | No |
| Brandon Judell | Culture Catch | 2008 | Yes |
| Rebekah Jones | The Daily Orange | 2008 | No |
| Rachel Jacobson | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Glenn Kenny | Some Came Running | 2008 | Yes |
| Erik Kohn | New York Press/indieWIRE | 2008 | No |
| Don Kaye | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Koresky | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Laura Kern | Film Comment | 2008 | Yes |
| Gary Kramer | Gay City News | 2008 | No |
| Peter Keough | Boston Phoenix | 2008 | Yes |
| Ben Kenigsberg | Time Out Chicago | 2008 | Yes |
| Jay Kuehner | Cinema Scope | 2008 | No |
| Adam Kempenaar | Filmspotting | 2008 | No |
| Zach Kewkirk | Times-Standard | 2008 | No |
| Susie Kopecky | thecelebritycafe.com | 2008 | No |
| Lisa Kennedy | Denver Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Christopher Kelly | DFW.com | 2008 | Yes |
| TC Kirkham | Popcorn n Roses | 2008 | No |
| Harry Knowles | AICN | 2008 | No |
| Peter Knegt | indieWIRE | 2008 | No |
| Harry Knowles | Ain't It Cool News | 2008 | No |
| Dave Kehr | DaveKehr.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Sally Kline | DC Examiner | 2008 | No |
| Anita Katz | San Francisco Examiner | 2008 | Yes |
| Jette Kernion | Cinemtical | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Knight | Nationl Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Andy Klein | Los Angeles City BEAT | 2008 | Yes |
| Chuck Koplinski | Illinois Times | 2008 | No |
| David Kempler | | 2008 | No |
| Ed Killingsworth | Valley Planet | 2008 | No |
| William Kerns | Lubbock Online | 2008 | No |
| Lou Lumenik | New York Post | 2008 | No |
| Anthony Lane | New Yorker | 2008 | Yes |
| Christy Lemire | AP | 2008 | Yes |
| Joanna Langfield | The Movie Minute | 2008 | Yes |
| Dennis Lim | Moving Image Source | 2008 | Yes |
| Nathan Lane | WNYC | 2008 | No |
| Laremy Legel | film.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Karina Longworth | SpoutBlog | 2008 | Yes |
| Phillip Lopate | indieWIRE | 2008 | Yes |
| Nathan Lee | New York Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Kurt Loder | MTV.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Kevin Lee | Shooting Pictures Down | 2008 | No |
| Joshua Land | Freelance | 2008 | Yes |
| Shawn Levy | The Oregonian | 2008 | Yes |
| Laremy Legal | Film.com | 2008 | No |
| Emanuel Levy | EmanuelLevy.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Long | Detroit News | 2008 | Yes |
| Mick LaSalle | San Francisco Gate | 2008 | Yes |
| Kevin LaForest | Montreal Film Journal | 2008 | No |
| Craig D. Lindsey | News & Observer | 2008 | Yes |
| Sheri Linden | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Lynch | Newcity | 2008 | No |
| Kristian Lin | Ft. Worth Weekly | 2008 | No |
| Matthew Lucas | The Dispatch | 2008 | No |
| Stuart Levine | RBI-US | 2008 | Yes |
| Jonathan Lack | yourhub.com | 2008 | Yes |
| George Lang | Newsok | 2008 | No |
| Germain Lussier | Times Herald Record | 2008 | No |
| Josh Larsen | Southtown Star | 2008 | Yes |
| Liam Lacey | Globe and Mail | 2008 | Yes |
| Jeffrey K. Lyles | Gazette | 2008 | No |
| Christopher Long | dvdtown.com | 2008 | Yes |
| William David Lee | dvdtown.com | 2008 | No |
| Rebecca Murray | About.com | 2008 | No |
| Noel Murray | The Onion | 2008 | No |
| Dave McCoy | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Kim Morgan | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Kathleen Murphy | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| MSN Movies | consensus | 2008 | No |
| Patrick McGavin | Stop Smiling | 2008 | No |
| Moviefone | | 2008 | No |
| Mairi Mackay | CNN | 2008 | No |
| Prairie Miller | News Blaze | 2008 | No |
| Roger Moore | Vindy.com | 2008 | No |
| Katherine Monk | Financial Post | 2008 | No |
| Jennifer Merin | About.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Nell Minow | Belienet.com | 2008 | No |
| Karen Martin | Arkansas Democrat-Gazette | 2008 | No |
| Maitland McDonagh | MissFlickChick.com | 2008 | No |
| Wilson Morales | Blackfilm.com | 2008 | No |
| Brian Miller | Seattle Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Kristi Mitsuda | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Amy Monaghan | pullquote.typepad.com | 2008 | No |
| Marc Mohan | The Oregonian | 2008 | Yes |
| Sean P. Means | Salt Lake Tribune | 2008 | No |
| Carla Meyer | Sacramento Bee | 2008 | No |
| Wesley Morris | Boston Herald | 2008 | No |
| Joe Morgenstern | Wall Street Journal | 2008 | No |
| Drew McWeeny | HitFlix | 2008 | No |
| Moira Macdonald | Seattle Times | 2008 | No |
| Phillip Martin | Arkansas Democrat | 2008 | No |
| Jarrett Martineau | | 2008 | No |
| Whitney Matheson | USA Today | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Meek | Boston Phoenix | 2008 | No |
| Mark Medley | National Post | 2008 | No |
| Neil Morris | Independent Weekly | 2008 | No |
| Brandy McDonnell | BAM | 2008 | No |
| Bob Mondello | NPR | 2008 | No |
| Bobby McCurdy | Insite Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Peter Martin | Cinematical | 2008 | No |
| Lisa Miller | Imperial Valley News | 2008 | Yes |
| Ron Martell | The Friday Flyer | 2008 | No |
| Wade Maki | Maki at the Movies | 2008 | No |
| Mike McGranaghan | The Aisle Seat | 2008 | No |
| Eric Melin | Scene Stealers | 2008 | No |
| Jolene Mendez | Entertainment Spectrum | 2008 | Yes |
| Danny Minton | Bearmont Journal | 2008 | No |
| VA Musetto | New York Post | 2008 | No |
| Cate Marquis | The Current Online | 2008 | No |
| Neil Miller | filmschoolrejects.com | 2008 | No |
| Jarrett Martineau | Now Public | 2008 | No |
| Don Marks | Skandies | 2008 | No |
| Victor Morton | skandies | 2008 | No |
| National Board of Review | | 2008 | No |
| New York Film Critics Online | | 2008 | No |
| Adam Nayman | Eye Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Rob Nelson | Freelance | 2008 | Yes |
| Daniel Neman | Richmond Times-Dispatch | 2008 | Yes |
| Tim Nasson | Wildaboutmovies.com | 2008 | No |
| Joe Neumier | New York Daily News | 2008 | No |
| Matt Newlin | Playback | 2008 | No |
| Michael Nowotny | Mountain Home News | 2008 | No |
| Christopher Null | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Amy Nicholson | Inland Empire Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Eugene Novikov | | 2008 | Yes |
| Nick Nunziata | CHUD.com | 2008 | Yes |
| David Nusair | Reel Film | 2008 | Yes |
| The Onion | | 2008 | No |
| Mark Olsen | Film Comment | 2008 | Yes |
| Michelle Orange | Village Voice | 2008 | Yes |
| Geogffrey O'Brien | indieWIRE poll | 2008 | No |
| Oklahoma Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Andrew O'Hehir | Salon.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Clint O'Connor | Cleveland Plain Dealer | 2008 | Yes |
| Craig Outhier | East Valley Tribune | 2008 | Yes |
| Josh Obligatory | Cinemablend | 2008 | No |
| Brian Orndorf | efilmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Eric Olsen | Blogcritics Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Sean O'Connell | WBTV | 2008 | Yes |
| Christopher Orr | New Republic | 2008 | Yes |
| Jeffrey Overstreet | Looking Closer | 2008 | Yes |
| Observer-Reporter | | 2008 | No |
| Charles O'Dell | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Paste Magazine | | 2008 | No |
| Milan Paurich | Cleveland Scene | 2008 | No |
| Phoenix Film Critics | | 2008 | No |
| Keith Phipps | The Onion | 2008 | Yes |
| Steve Persall | Time Film Critic | 2008 | Yes |
| Richard Porton | Cineaste | 2008 | Yes |
| Mary Pols | Women On Film | 2008 | No |
| Andrea Picard | Cinematheque Ontario | 2008 | No |
| Gerald Peary | Boston Phoenix | 2008 | Yes |
| Nick Pinkerton | Village Voice | 2008 | Yes |
| David Poland | Movie City News | 2008 | Yes |
| Ray Pride | Movie City News | 2008 | Yes |
| Premiere Magazine | | 2008 | No |
| Betsy Pickle | Women on Film | 2008 | No |
| Matt Pais, Red Eye | Chicago | 2008 | No |
| Ed Perkins | CinemaBlend | 2008 | No |
| Adam Palcher | Salt Lake Magazine | 2008 | No |
| Ed Perkis | cinemablend.com | 2008 | No |
| Steve Prokopy | Gapers Block | 2008 | No |
| Matthew Price | Newsok | 2008 | No |
| Craig Phillips | GreenCine | 2008 | Yes |
| Matt Price | Newsok | 2008 | No |
| John J. Puccio | DVDtown.com | 2008 | Yes |
| James Plath | dvdtown.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Matt Prigge | Philadelphia Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Ian Pugh | Film Freak Central | 2008 | No |
| Pop Matters | | 2008 | No |
| Michael Phillips | Chicago Tribune | 2008 | Yes |
| Dustin Putman | The Movie Boy | 2008 | Yes |
| Pajiba | | 2008 | No |
| Sheridan Passell | Movie Moron | 2008 | No |
| Leonard Pierce | Nerve.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Mark Pittillo | skandies | 2008 | No |
| James Quandt | Cinematheque Ontario | 2008 | Yes |
| Richard Roeper | Chicago Sun-Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Rex Reed | New York Observer | 2008 | Yes |
| Nathan Rabin | The Onion | 2008 | Yes |
| Tasha Robinson | The Onion | 2008 | Yes |
| James Rocchi | MSN Movies | 2008 | Yes |
| Jonathan Rosenbaum | | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Ryan | The Age | 2008 | Yes |
| Vadim Rizov | indieWIRE poll | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Joshua Rowin | The L Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Rene Rodriguez | Miami Herald | 2008 | Yes |
| Berenice Reynaud | Senses of Cinema | 2008 | Yes |
| B. Ruby Rich | The Guardian | 2008 | Yes |
| Nick Rapold | Film Comment | 2008 | No |
| Joshua Rothkopf | Time Out New York | 2008 | Yes |
| Jim Ridley | Nashville Scene | 2008 | Yes |
| River Front Times Critical Mass | | 2008 | No |
| Mike Russell | The Oregonian | 2008 | Yes |
| Matty Robinson | Filmspotting | 2008 | No |
| Sandhu Robey | The Telegraph | 2008 | No |
| Volkmar Richter | Vancouver 24 Hours | 2008 | No |
| Neil Rosen | NY1 | 2008 | Yes |
| Peter Rainer | Christian Science Monitor | 2008 | Yes |
| Rob Rector | Blogcritics | 2008 | No |
| Larry Ratliff | Sanantonio Express News | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Rechtshaffen | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Katey Rich | CinemaBlend.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Rosen | Cincinnati City Beat | 2008 | No |
| Ranjankul | Entertainmentandshowbiz.com | 2008 | No |
| Iann Robinson | Craveonline | 2008 | Yes |
| Josh Rosenblatt | Austin Chronicle | 2008 | Yes |
| Tom Ryan | Rotten Tomatoes Editor | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Rea | Philadelphia Inquirer | 2008 | No |
| Carrie Rickey | Philadelphia Inquirer | 2008 | Yes |
| Rama | Ramascreen.com | 2008 | No |
| Zach Ralston | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Scott Renshaw | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Sight & Sound | | 2008 | No |
| Kyle Smith | New York Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Southeastern Film Crtics Association | | 2008 | No |
| Nick Schager | Slant Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Lisa Schwarzbaum | Entertainment Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Andrew Schenker | Slant Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Matt Singer | IFC | 2008 | Yes |
| David Sterritt | davidsterritt.com | 2008 | Yes |
| A.O. Scott | New York Times | 2008 | Yes |
| R. Emmet Sweeney | IFC | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Sicinski | Cinema Scope | 2008 | Yes |
| Benjamin Strong | Freelance | 2008 | Yes |
| Hank Sartin | Time Out Chicago | 2008 | Yes |
| Chuck Stephens | Film Comment | 2008 | Yes |
| Felipe Solis | NewspaperTree.com | 2008 | No |
| Josh Serba | The Grand Rapids Press | 2008 | No |
| Michael Sragow | Baltimore Sun | 2008 | Yes |
| Ruth Stein | San Francisco Gate | 2008 | No |
| Dan Sallitt | Auterus Noteboo | 2008 | Yes |
| James Sanford | mlive.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Peter Sobczynski | eFilmCritic | 2008 | Yes |
| Frank Scheck | The Hollywood Reporter | 2008 | Yes |
| Eric D. Snider | film.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Jay Stone | Calgary Herald | 2008 | Yes |
| Dana Stevens | Slate | 2008 | Yes |
| Janet Smith | Straight.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Bob Strauss | LA.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Steven Snyder | TimeOut Film | 2008 | Yes |
| Mike Scott | The Times Picayune | 2008 | Yes |
| Mark Savlov | Austin Chronicle | 2008 | No |
| Duncan Shepherd | San Diego Reader | 2008 | No |
| Russ Simmons | KC Tribune | 2008 | No |
| Steve Salles | Standard Examiner | 2008 | No |
| Ed Symkus | Wicked Local Hudson | 2008 | No |
| Joe Sims | People's Weekly World | 2008 | No |
| Mike Shulz | River Cities' Reader | 2008 | No |
| Norm Schrager | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| TT Stern-Enzi | Dayton City Paper | 2008 | No |
| Justin Souther | Mountain Express | 2008 | No |
| Sara Schieron | Rotten Tomatoes Editor | 2008 | No |
| Diana Saenger | Review Express | 2008 | Yes |
| Mike Sage | My Kawartha.Com | 2008 | Yes |
| Cole Smithey | Colesmithey.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Sizzling Popcorn.com | | 2008 | No |
| Andy Scott | Everything Oscar | 2008 | No |
| Missy Schwartz | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Stults | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Froilan Vispo | skandies | 2008 | No |
| Pete Travers | Rolling Stone | 2008 | No |
| Kris Tapley | In Contention | 2008 | No |
| Scott Tobias | AV Club | 2008 | Yes |
| Michael Tully | Hammer to Nail | 2008 | No |
| Kenneth Turan | Los Angeles Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Charles Taylor | Daily Planet | 2008 | Yes |
| Amy Taubin | Film Comment | 2008 | Yes |
| Anne Thompson | Variety | 2008 | Yes |
| Erin Trahan | The Independent | 2008 | No |
| Josh Tyler | CinemaBlend | 2008 | No |
| Gina Telaroli | takepart.com | 2008 | No |
| Rob Tangney | KIRO Radio | 2008 | No |
| Ella Taylor | LA Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| Josh Tate | LAist | 2008 | No |
| Joanne Thornborough | The Daily Journal | 2008 | No |
| Gene Triplett | Newsok | 2008 | No |
| Bob Thompson | National Post | 2008 | Yes |
| Kent Tentschert | Webster-Kirkwood Times | 2008 | No |
| Lawrence Toppman | Charlotte Observer | 2008 | Yes |
| Martin Thomas | Spill.com | 2008 | No |
| Yair Raveh | Cinemascopian | 2008 | No |
| Susan Tavernetti | Palo Alto | 2008 | Yes |
| Andrea Tuccillo | the Cinema Source | 2008 | No |
| NP Thompson | Movies Into Film | 2008 | No |
| Devin Thomas | The Swinging Bridge | 2008 | No |
| Brian Tallerico | VideoHound | 2008 | Yes |
| Adam Tobias | Watertown Daily Times | 2008 | Yes |
| Fred Topel | Can Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Christian Toto | What Would Toto Watch | 2008 | Yes |
| John M. Urbanich | Cleveland Sun-Times | 2008 | No |
| Sara Vilkomerson | New York Observor | 2008 | Yes |
| Boyd van Hoeij | Variety | 2008 | Yes |
| Elbert Ventura | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Kim Voynar Movie City News | | 2008 | No |
| Sara Voorhees | American Woman Film Jouralists | 2008 | Yes |
| Phil Villarreal | Arizona Star | 2008 | Yes |
| James Verniere | Boston Herald | 2008 | Yes |
| Barbara Vancheri | Pittsburgh, Post-Gazette | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Vetter | Leader-Telegram | 2008 | No |
| Lynn Venhaus | News Democrat | 2008 | No |
| Eric Vespe | Ain't It Cool News | 2008 | No |
| Richard von Busack | Cinematical | 2008 | Yes |
| Jason Vargo | dvdtown.com | 2008 | No |
| John Waters | Art Forum | 2008 | No |
| Jeffrey Wells | Hollywood Elsewhere | 2008 | Yes |
| Susan Wloszczyna | USA Today | 2008 | Yes |
| Matthew Wilder | Collider.com | 2008 | No |
| Bill Weber | Slant Magazine | 2008 | Yes |
| Chris Wisniewski | Reverse Shot | 2008 | Yes |
| Alison Willmore | IFC | 2008 | Yes |
| Bruce Watson | Belletin Contributing Writer | 2008 | No |
| Chuck Wilson | LA Weekly | 2008 | Yes |
| David Walsh | World Socialist Web Site | 2008 | No |
| Steve Warren | Hook | 2008 | No |
| Joe Williams | St Louis Post-Dispatch | 2008 | Yes |
| Stephen Whitty | New Jersey Star Ledger | 2008 | Yes |
| James Ward | Visalia Times-Delta | 2008 | No |
| Calvin Wilson | STL Today | 2008 | Yes |
| George Wu | Culture Vulture | 2008 | Yes |
| Emmett Williams | Minneapolis Examiner | 2008 | No |
| Bill Wine | Celebrity News Service | 2008 | No |
| Elizabeth Weitzman | New York Daily News | 2008 | Yes |
| Bob Wynn | Nashville City Paper | 2008 | No |
| Michael Wilmington | Movie City News | 2008 | Yes |
| Gary Wolcott | atomictown.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Don Willmott | filmcritic.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Bill White | Seattle Post | 2008 | Yes |
| The Week | | 2008 | No |
| Karn Williams | Tri-State Defender | 2008 | No |
| Daniel Waters | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Andrew Wright | skandies | 2008 | Yes |
| Ryan Wu | skandies | 2008 | No |
| William Wolf | | 2008 | No |
| Stephanie Zacharek | Salon.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Ron Yamauchi | Straight.com | 2008 | Yes |
| Pamela Zoslov | Cleveland Scene | 2008 | Yes |
| Brian Zitzelman | Seattle Movie Examiner | 2008 | No |
| Jen Yamato | Rotten Tomatoes Editor | 2008 | Yes |